Bringing Buddha to the newsroom: media with mindfulness
How about a few minutes of meditation to kick off your next newsroom meeting?
It’s a frequent practice at News Deeply, a New York-based startup that focuses on comprehensive coverage of complex issues that are widely overhyped and misunderstood, such as Syria, refugees, oceans, and water.
Under such a “huge cognitive load,” says Lara Setrakian, the CEO and co-founder, “[mindfulness practice] has been a huge practical boost for us. I’ve also seen it really shape our decision-making as an organization.”
Journalism’s institutions are late to adopt mindfulness, a practice of developing an awareness of our thoughts (often through meditation) that at its best can make us more reflective, more empathic, and less reactive. Already well integrated into many established organizations and corporations, including Aetna, Target, Google, and the World Bank, to name a few, it has been shown to reduce stress, and to improve both performance and corporate social responsibility. Yet little has been said about how mindfulness could enable, and in some cases already is enabling, better storytelling.
Arianna Huffington, whose devotion to mindfulness is well documented, was perhaps the first contemporary media entrepreneur to point out that “if we stay with ‘it bleeds it leads,’ we’re going to really miss out on all the things that transform our world.” That sentiment is driving many journalists into areas of news that are meant to help society, like solutions journalism, constructive journalism, positive news, and impact journalism.
“They all encourage a more mindful approach to our work,” says Mark Pearson, a professor of journalism and social media at Griffith University, in a Skype interview. “They’re each chipping away at it in a different way.”
Practically speaking, mindfulness can help journalists make choices in accord with the profession’s best practices: more long-term reporting on issues of public importance, more diversity of sources, more emphasis on solutions, and less fear-mongering.
“We leave [the mainstream] because the industry as a whole isn’t living up to its mandate. It’s not any one organization, it’s system-wide—it’s a design defect,” Setrakian tells CJR. As an industry, she continues, “we are navel-gazers, but it doesn’t mean we’re self-regulating and adequately self-reflective.”
That lack of reflection often results in formulaic practices that “don’t serve the user and don’t result in an optimal outcome, which is high-fidelity information,” she says.
Reflection, even in the time it takes for a smoke break, can help minimize the risks associated with hasty and unconscious decision-making.
Clinical psychologist and mindfulness teacher Dr. Donna Rockwell says she can’t imagine a field that could benefit more from mindfulness practice than journalism.
“Journalism has to be a higher calling,” she tells CJR. Rockwell is a former journalist who worked with the late Daniel Schorr, who had an illustrious career at CBS, CNN, and NPR. “Mindfulness helps us stop being able to tell ourselves bologna—it’s an internal integrity meter. The more we use it, the less we’ll be drawn to a sensational interpretation,” she says.
The insight and emotional intelligence that comes from a mindful state naturally leads to ethical decision-making, says Pearson. Using Buddha’s Four Noble Truths as a framework, his co-authored book Mindful Journalism and News Ethics in the Digital Era provides a scholarly roadmap for a more conscious, self-aware kind of journalism.
Buddha’s truths “offer a secular lens through which we can view our ethical behavior as individuals and as journalists,” Pearson says.
He concedes that ethics are often in conflict with the pressures of a real-time news desk, but says that reflection, even in the time it takes for a smoke break, can help minimize the risks associated with hasty and unconscious decision-making. Journalists, Pearson suggests, could adopt a reflective practice that might change how a story is told simply by thinking about how the information could affect consumers: “Is my story going to help reduce suffering, or is it going to increase it?”
When she started News Deeply, Setrakian says she saw a need to cover the “blind spots” being overlooked or sloppily framed by media. A mindful approach, she explains, can defuse even the most polarized conversation and turn it into something more diverse. “Mindfulness brings us down from the ivory tower, and helps us get closer to the ground in every way, intellectually as well.”
Setrakian says the entrepreneurial sphere is already influencing the mainstream, which, she says, “is still made up of people who mean well and want to do good. They are noticing a culture change, and I do believe it’s having a systematic impact.” She notes that News Deeply’s stories have been referenced by outlets across the political spectrum, from Breitbart to The New York Times, particularly related to coverage of Syria.
Salon.com staff writer Mary Elizabeth Williams has embraced that culture change and incorporated it into her craft. “I’m definitely trying to apply mindfulness to my work, especially now, in this new administration,” she writes in an email to CJR. In 2015, Williams was part of a mindfulness session offered to reporters covering war and conflict by the Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma at the Columbia Journalism School.
Williams says the practice allows her to cope with writing about difficult situations like the Manchester bombing. “I feel it’s important to keep doing what we do, and it’s also important to remember our self care, every day,” she says.
Rockwell agrees. “Because news is so fast-paced, and news means real-time observation of impermanence, it really behooves us to be able to stay present and to not be swept away in our minds by this or that analysis, but rather to have enough space around all of that to be more emotionally intelligent.”
More journalists are awakening to the idea that business as usual isn’t sustainable. Maybe part of the antidote is a degree of mindfulness—whether practiced as an individual or as a newsroom.
“It is for the health and vitality—for the life—of democracy,” Rockwell says.
A little mindfulness in the profession may no longer be a choice, but an ethical imperative, to help foster more principled journalism and rebuild trust in the media.
Behind the unlikely success of PolitiFact and the Truth-O-Meter
There were lots of good reasons we shouldn’t have started PolitiFact. We were out of our league. The St. Petersburg Times was a regional paper with a good reputation, but we didn’t know much about fact-checking or developing new products in a digital age. I knew nothing about building a website. My first diagram of …
Coral Project guides to audience engagement teach newsrooms how to fish
What are the legal concerns for newsrooms that host their own comments? What metrics should you be using to measure engagement? How you manage a commenter who repeatedly harasses others? Audience engagement can be a daunting project for newsrooms to tackle on their own—but an important one, especially in an era of declining trust in …
Journalism is a public service. Why don’t we fund it like one?
LOCAL NEWS IS IN DIRE STRAITS. In a quest for profit, publishers have gutted newsrooms and hollowed out coverage of local communities. As the industry struggles to build the business model of the future, it’s missing an opportunity to embrace a funding mechanism that can enshrine journalism as a public service: the special service district. …
Spinoff from Blavity caters to young black women
Entrepreneur Morgan DeBaun saw a gap in lifestyle coverage catering to young women of color and wanted to do something about it. Her solution: 21Ninety, a lifestyle-news website featuring articles and videos on topics like beauty, health, and fitness through the lens of black women. As the founder of a news site for black millennials, …
‘Tough, frightening, funny, tender’: A new podcast chronicles life behind bars
Earlonne Woods’s room is the size of a large walk-in closet. It has a toilet, a sink, two lockers, a bunk bed, and a handful of personal belongings. Plus, two grown men. It’s a four-by-nine-foot cell inside California’s San Quentin State Prison. Woods jokes that he can touch one wall while his back is still …
New York Daily News: In praise of Facebook Instant Articles
The New York Daily News has recently gone all in on Facebook Instant. After eschewing the format for months, it now posts 92 percent of its links on Facebook as Instant Articles, according to research from the Tow Center for Digital Journalism. The Daily News move comes as major publishers such as The New York …
Senegalese rappers make news with a beat
A typical episode of Journal Rappé begins with Senegalese rapper Makhtar “Xuman” Fall dressed in a suit and seated behind a news desk. At first glance, the show looks like an ordinary newscast. But then Xuman (pronounced human) launches into his intro, rapping in French instead of talking. “Welcome! Make yourself comfortable. These are the …
How to report on algorithms even if you’re not a data whiz
There’s a new beat in town: algorithms. From formulas that determine what you see on social media to equations that dictate government operations, algorithms are increasingly powerful and pervasive. As an important new field of influence, algorithms are ripe for journalistic investigation. But investigating computer code can come across as dry and technical. Researchers often …
Texas journalists collaborate on nonprofit to share data, enrich reporting
A FEW YEARS AGO, SOME AUSTIN, TEXAS, residents were up in arms over “stealth dorms.” As the city council debated occupancy limits, Austin Monitor publisher Michael Kanin realized he couldn’t answer a basic question: How many stealth dorms were there? Dan Zehr had the same question. “The city council was deliberating this basically off of …
Facebook’s moderation is of public interest. It should be public knowledge.
When Facebook announced two weeks ago that it would hire an extra 3,000 moderators to review livestreamed video, many wondered what moderating the vast platform might actually look like. This week, The Guardian exclusively obtained documents that allow a more detailed look inside the Facebook moderation processes than ever before. It is clear from the …
Facebook paid pubs to use Live. Here’s what happened at the Times.
The number of live videos posted to The New York Times’ main Facebook page has consistently surpassed regular videos in the 12 months since Facebook began paying select media partners to use its nascent streaming platform—yet viewing figures for Facebook Live lag far behind. The Times is one of about 140 media companies and celebrities the platform …
A focus on digital habits could help news publishers fight Facebook
Clay Johnson’s 2013 book, The Information Diet, lamented the state of people’s news and media habits in the digital age. In it, he compared online users’ media consumption to the obesity epidemic—we consume too little that is good for us and too much fatty, substance-less content—and laid out his “case for conscious consumption.” Four years …
Startup that promises ‘no-bullshit journalism’ nets serious cash
Last Wednesday, shortly before 7 am, Constantin Seibt took a few deep breaths to steady himself before walking the last block to Zurich’s Hotel Rothaus, a former brothel-turned-hotel-turned-temporary office for a journalism startup called Republik. It was the first day of a crowdfunding effort to prove to investors there was market support for an online …
Journalists and screenwriters team up for a new TV series inspired by El Chapo
In September 2013, Univision investigative journalist Gerardo Reyes turned down an interview with a source he had been chasing for years. The notorious Mexican drug trafficker Joaquín Guzmán Loera, widely known as “El Chapo,” had agreed to an interview with Reyes—with the caveat that he wanted approval on the final product. Reyes declined. “We don’t …
A master audio storyteller on how to create a powerful podcast
To say podcasting is having a moment is an understatement. The team behind Serial’s latest blockbuster, S-Town, recently broke records with 16 million downloads in the first week. Traditional news outlets like The New York Times and NPR are currently battling it out for the top spot on the daily news podcast beat. And Buzzfeed announced …